Nottingham Forest vs Everton F.C. Stats – Head-to-Head Record and Analysis

Nottingham Forest and Everton have built one of English football’s more intriguing historical rivalries, with their head-to-head record spanning multiple decades and competitions. The two clubs have met 143 times across all competitions, with Everton holding a clear overall advantage in victories. However, their Premier League encounters since Forest’s return to the top flight have told a more nuanced story, particularly at the City Ground where Everton have proven particularly difficult to beat in recent years.

The latest chapter in this fixture was written on December 30, 2025, when Everton claimed a 2-0 victory at the City Ground, with James Garner earning Player of the Match honours despite a depleted squad. The result extended Everton’s remarkable unbeaten run away to Forest, highlighting a trend that has frustrated the home side’s ambitions in recent seasons. Understanding the full statistical picture of this fixture requires examining both the comprehensive historical record and the specific patterns that have emerged in Premier League competition.

For supporters seeking detailed Nottingham Forest vs Everton FC stats, this analysis draws from multiple sources including club records, official Premier League statistics, and dedicated football analytics platforms to present a comprehensive overview of their head-to-head history, recent form, and the factors that have shaped their most memorable encounters. Those interested in broader football statistics might also find our coverage of the Cork City vs Waterford match report useful for understanding statistical trends across different leagues.

What is the Head-to-Head Record Between Nottingham Forest and Everton?

Across 143 meetings in all competitions, Everton have established themselves as the dominant force in this fixture. The Toffees have secured 64 victories, representing 44.8% of all encounters, while Nottingham Forest have managed 44 wins, or 30.8% of the total. The remaining 35 matches have ended in draws, accounting for 24.5% of their historical meetings.

• Total Matches Played: 143 (all competitions)
• Everton Wins: 64 (44.8%)
• Nottingham Forest Wins: 44 (30.8%)
• Draws: 35 (24.5%)
• Everton unbeaten in last 5 away matches at City Ground (W3 D2)

Premier League Head-to-Head Snapshot

The historical data reveals that Everton’s advantage extends beyond simple win counts. Their superior goal-scoring rate of 1.4-1.5 goals per game compared to Forest’s 0.7-0.8 demonstrates a consistent ability to convert chances against their rivals. This scoring disparity has been particularly evident in recent Premier League encounters, where Everton have found ways to win even when Forest have dominated possession.

Recent Match Results: Nottingham Forest vs Everton

Everton’s recent dominance in this fixture is striking. In the last 10 Premier League meetings between the clubs, Everton have claimed victory in six occasions, while Forest have failed to win any of those encounters, managing four draws instead. This run of form has seen Everton establish psychological supremacy in the fixture, particularly when playing away from Goodison Park.

Key Results from Recent Seasons

The December 2025 fixture saw Forest control 70% of possession with an expected goals figure of 1.55 compared to Everton’s 1.26, yet it was the visitors who emerged victorious through clinical finishing. This result exemplified Everton’s effectiveness in this fixture, having won both their away games during 2025 despite rarely dominating territorial statistics. The April 2025 encounter proved equally frustrating for Forest, with Abdoulaye Doucouré scoring a dramatic 94th-minute winner that significantly dented Forest’s UEFA Champions League qualification hopes.

Forest’s most recent victory in this fixture came at Goodison Park in December 2024, a result that provided brief optimism for their supporters. However, subsequent encounters have reinforced Everton’s upper hand, with the Toffees winning three of the next four meetings. The March 2023 2-2 draw remains Forest’s most recent positive result at the City Ground, though even that match saw Everton twice take the lead before Forest equalised late.

Home, Away, and Goal Stats for Nottingham Forest vs Everton

The venue has proven crucial in determining outcomes between these sides. At the City Ground, Everton have developed a particularly strong record, winning four of their last seven Premier League visits while Forest managed just one victory. The average goal count of 2.1 per game suggests tightly contested affairs, though Everton’s superior conversion rate has often made the difference.

Home and Away Performance Analysis

Everton’s away record against Forest stands out as exceptional in the Premier League era. The Toffees have remained unbeaten in their last five visits to the City Ground, winning three and drawing two. This run includes the 2-0 victory in December 2025 and the dramatic 1-0 win in April 2025, both demonstrating Everton’s ability to secure results even when second best in terms of overall play.

Goal Statistics Breakdown

The goal statistics reveal a significant disparity in attacking efficiency. Forest’s struggles to convert chances against Everton are reflected in their average of less than one goal per game, while Everton have been nearly twice as productive. This attacking advantage has translated into tangible results, with Everton winning both the aggregate scores and the majority of individual matchups in recent seasons.

Current Form and Key Player Stats Comparison

The 2024-25 Premier League season presented contrasting trajectories for both clubs. Forest challenged for UEFA Champions League qualification, finishing with 17 wins, 6 draws, and 9 defeats to accumulate 57 points. Everton, meanwhile, endured a more difficult campaign, managing just 8 wins from 32 games to end with 38 points, significantly below their traditional standards.

Recent Head-to-Head Form Guide

Forest’s winless streak in recent head-to-head meetings is reflected in their form guide, with zero victories in their last five encounters against Everton. Their goals-for rate of 1.0 per game against the Toffees falls well below their season average, suggesting Everton have successfully nullified their attacking threats. Everton’s balanced record of two wins, one draw, and two defeats indicates competitiveness, though their superior goals-for rate demonstrates greater effectiveness in the final third.

Key Performers in Recent Encounters

Several players have shaped recent meetings between these clubs. For Forest, Morgan Gibbs-White has been a consistent presence, though he missed a crucial chance in the April 2025 fixture that could have secured Forest’s first win in the fixture for some time. Chris Wood has led the line effectively, while Callum Hudson-Odoi and Murillo have contributed to Forest’s attacking efforts. The defensive trio of Morato, Milenkovic, and Williams has faced repeated pressure from Everton’s counter-attacks.

Everton’s key figures have delivered in critical moments. Abdoulaye Doucouré’s dramatic 94th-minute winner in April 2025 encapsulated Everton’s ability to steal results, earning him widespread recognition. James Garner proved instrumental in the December 2025 victory, earning Player of the Match honours despite playing for a depleted Everton side. Jarrad Branthwaite has demonstrated solidity at the back, while the midfield pairing of Iroegbunam and Obling have contributed to Everton’s tactical discipline against Forest’s possession-based approach.

Timeline of Recent Premier League Encounters

The chronological sequence of recent meetings reveals patterns in this fixture’s development. From Forest’s return to the Premier League in 2022 through late 2025, the clubs have met seven times in top-flight competition, with Everton winning six of those encounters. The timeline demonstrates both the consistency of Everton’s dominance and Forest’s occasional ability to compete effectively.

1. December 30, 2025: Nottingham Forest 0-2 Everton (City Ground) – Garner stellar as depleted Everton win
2. April 12, 2025: Nottingham Forest 0-1 Everton (City Ground) – Doucouré 90+4′ winner
3. December 29, 2024: Everton 0-2 Nottingham Forest (Goodison Park) – Forest’s sole recent victory
4. April 21, 2024: Everton 2-0 Nottingham Forest (Goodison Park) – Everton respond strongly
5. December 2, 2023: Nottingham Forest 1-0 Everton (City Ground) – Tight contest
6. March 5, 2023: Nottingham Forest 2-2 Everton (City Ground) – Highest-scoring recent meeting
7. August 20, 2022: Everton 1-1 Nottingham Forest (Goodison Park) – Season opener

The most dramatic moment in this sequence came in April 2025, when Doucouré’s stoppage-time goal not only secured victory but also significantly impacted Forest’s Champions League qualification ambitions. Conversely, Forest’s December 2024 triumph at Goodison Park provided one of their rare positive moments against Everton in recent seasons.

What the Data Tells Us and What Remains Unclear

The statistical record between Nottingham Forest and Everton presents a clear picture in several areas while leaving some questions unanswered.

The data consistently demonstrates Everton’s effectiveness in this fixture, particularly at the City Ground. However, granular statistics such as expected goals breakdowns for individual players across all meetings remain sparse, limiting deeper tactical analysis. Additionally, while the December 2025 match was recorded as Round 19 of the Premier League season, details about future scheduling beyond this point were not available in the source data.

Historical Context and League Implications

The Nottingham Forest versus Everton fixture carries particular significance given the clubs’ different trajectories in recent years. Forest’s return to the Premier League in 2022 marked the beginning of an ambitious project that saw them challenge for European qualification by 2024-25. Everton, despite their historical superiority in this fixture, have faced their own challenges, with points deductions and managerial changes disrupting their usual mid-table stability.

The psychological dimension of this fixture should not be underestimated. Everton’s consistent ability to take points from Forest, particularly away from home, has created a mental barrier that Forest have struggled to overcome. Even when Forest have dominated possession and created the clearer chances, as in December 2025, Everton have demonstrated a capacity to win ugly when necessary.

For Forest, breaking this hoodoo represents a significant target. Their sole victory in recent meetings came at Goodison Park, but repeating that success at the City Ground has proven elusive. As both clubs continue to evolve, with Forest pushing for European football and Everton rebuilding under new leadership, this fixture is likely to retain its competitive edge.

Sources and References

The statistical data presented in this analysis draws from multiple authoritative sources in football statistics and club records.

“Everton have a strong record against Nottingham Forest across all competitions, with the Toffees winning 64 of their 143 meetings.”

Source: 11v11.com

“Forest have won just three of their 14 Premier League meetings with Everton since 1992, with the Toffees maintaining a dominant head-to-head record in the modern era.”

Source: AiScore

“Doucouré’s 90+4 minute winner in April 2025 gave Everton a dramatic victory at the City Ground, denting Forest’s Champions League qualification hopes.”

Source: ESPN

Summary

Nottingham Forest and Everton have contested 143 matches across all competitions, with Everton holding a decisive advantage of 64 victories to Forest’s 44. In Premier League encounters since Forest’s 2022 return to the top flight, Everton have proven particularly dominant at the City Ground, remaining unbeaten in their last five visits while winning three. Forest’s sole victory in recent seasons came at Goodison Park in December 2024, though Everton responded immediately with victories in both 2025 meetings. The Toffees’ superior goal-scoring rate of 1.4-1.5 goals per game compared to Forest’s 0.7-0.8 highlights the attacking efficiency that has characterised their success in this fixture. For those tracking Cork City vs Waterford match report or Semenyo next club odds, this fixture demonstrates how historical data informs expectations for upcoming encounters.

Frequently Asked Questions